Penfolds Bin 707 Cabernet Sauvignon 1996

Jane Anson: Charred oak notes, campfire smoke, rosebud, a little angular at first, striking how young this feels at 28 years old, tannins not yet fully resolved although heading towards long limbed. There is precision here, and a lovely shot of mint freshness giving a cushioning lift through the finish, along with recurrant, blackberry and cassis fruits, and a swirl of espresso and cigar box. Grows and unfurls in the glass, with a low hum of energy, has a long life ahead. 100% new American oak. 94/100 (2024)

Jancis Robinson: Lots there! Satin texture and lots of Cab fruit plus coconut oak. A bit obvious. But for the age it is still very lively. Tough, green finish. 15/20 (2004)